Protoss in SC2S

[Protogod]

Bottom line, since we don't have a clean consensus in the plot thread - should we involve the protoss in our first sc2s campaign?

[Dark_Soul74]

I don't think they have a good place in our current plot arc. Including them would just feel cheap, since it's a short arc. We'd only realistically be able to include them for a short while, or else they'd have to come in freakishly early or too late to really be accepted. My thoughts, at least. If we are to include them, it should be another project. We'll have extra people anyway.

[Fiendwurm]

I think they should be opponents, and they should be playable, at different ends of the campain. when the players are raiding that city, the protoss are against the players, and are with them, when there overthrowing the crazy guy

[Dark_Soul74]

I think they should be opponents, and they should be playable, at different ends of the campain. when the players are raiding that city, the protoss are against the players, and are with them, when there overthrowing the crazy guyI'm not sure what you're suggesting here. What city? >>

[DarkMirror]

Lol, I think he mixed both storylines togethor!

[Dark_Soul74]

Well, what exactly are we going to do? I think it's a bit odd that we have 8 votes, 4 posts, and a lack of understanding concerning the actual plot we've chosen. D:

I think a meeting or something could help clear things up, considering just about anyone can vote in our official polls. >>

[Protogod]

Thus far, consensus is that they should be involved in one way or another.

I would like everyone to be on MSN as much as possible, though. We need to discuss this.

[TitanWing]

Well, what exactly are we going to do? I think it's a bit odd that we have 8 votes, 4 posts, and a lack of understanding concerning the actual plot we've chosen. D:

I think a meeting or something could help clear things up, considering just about anyone can vote in our official polls. >>
Can't you make "public" polls that say who voted for what? That way we could weed out any non SC2S...personnel.

On the poll, I'm voting against 'Toss. They simply don't fit into the storyline easily, and I think any effort to get them in would come across as an afterthought sqeezed into it. Terran and Zerg will do just fine, we can focus on the Protoss in our 2nd project.

[Dark_Soul74]

Can't you make "public" polls that say who voted for what? That way we could weed out any non SC2S...personnel.Which is why this poll in particular confuses me. We've got two people talking against them, one guy saying we should include them in what appears to be the other campaign, one guy who hasn't explained himself, but six votes for including the Protoss.

Our posts say: 50% no, 25% yes, and 25% unknown, but our poll says: 60% yes, 30% no, and 10% unknown. Fairly large difference, if you ask me. Considering that actually reading the story is more important than caring about the Protoss here, I'd say a poll just gives people who haven't even read the plot a chance to interfere. :concern: