jumping on the bandwagon

[blaxican_templar]

so..everyone else is doing it,so i decideed to make a thread about it, who do YOU guys think`would win??? The entire starcraft group vs. the entire starwars group.. LET THE BATTLE BEGIN!!! ps.must have REAL evidence to support your descision,nothing like: the protoss would win cause there tight or cooler. or: a jedi would win cause its stupid to have a jedi fight a zealot*glares at mr.bad*

[william_clinch]

I'd say Starcraft
The general humans are better in starcraft, (geneticly created for battle or something) where as the starwars humans are the same as todays humans

Starcraft 'monsters'(zerg) are way cooler, erm I mean deadlyer than almost anything from the starwars universe (and jaba is just a celibate wanabe)

As the for the force, a templar would easyly whip a jedi or sith, as they have far more powers at there disposal, and if they whip out the Archons, even all the jedi combined would fall

As for the ships
Ties/X-wings Vs Wraiths/Scouts
Wraiths can cloak, and Scouts have strong sheilds, where as ties have almost no protection at all, and X-wings can either go fast, or attack, but not both at the same time

Star Destroyer Vs Capital ships
If it was one on one, the star destroyer might win, unless the battle crusier used it's yamoto cannon. The reson, because star destroyers as well as haveing loads of lazers, (like a battle crusier) it also has lots of ships (like a carrier) so the best chances are if a carrier and crusier teamed up

Death star Vs .....
There isn't realy anything as big as the deathstar, except....




The Xel'Naga tempel

Although that isn't realy that practical
Not sure what special abilities would work on the DS though
Mind controll probabl wouldn't, lockdown would only affect a portion of it, but stasis feild would criple it. Spawn broodlings might also work...

The robots

R2-D2 Vs Reaver
-R2-D2: bleep bleep bloody bleep [translation: I am a retatd]
-Reaver:Xuang! [translation] Die N00B!
-Scarrab:AAAAARRRRGGG KABOOM!!
R2-D2 has died
-C-3PO: Finaly I'm free of that annoying crettin
C-3PO joins the protoss

Other
Tassadar Vs Yoda- ends with tasadar standing over a smokeing pile of green goo
Zeratul Vs Darth Vader- After being confused because he cant see he aponent, vaders head mystiriously detatches from its body
Kerigan Vs Leia- They decide to do something else instead of fight
Duran Vs Mace Windoo- *snipe
Jar Jar Binks Vs anything- Jar jar ends up killing himself

[LordOfNukes]

StarCraft > Star Wars

I'd like to see a jedi block a Yomato blast, :p. Psionic Storm is also going to cvause a lot of painf ro the jedis. Even if you had the evil sith lightning thing, a High templar would own, and an Archon would just walk over and incerinate the sith guy. The jedi jumping abilties will be useful for them, but they'd still get owned. Bullets unlike laser beams won't be reflected by the light saber. Instead they would probably melt splattering the jedi's face with molten lead.

[blaxican_templar]

well... you cant EXACTLY say that templar would win JUST cause they have more powers.... all we knwow about so far is hallucinate,psi-storm.. and er...theres another one.Dark archons have MC,but it doesn't work as well cause 1.only one thing at a time 2. it drains almost all of its energy. Jedi mind tricks can work on multiple targets and an experianced jedi like luke can use dozensa of times at once. EX: in "specter of the past" luke was fighting like 30 tie-fighters and a gun ship by himself, luke just used a mind trick to confuse the pilots and they all ended up attacking each other and crashing into each other. also`how do you know that SC monsters are better?? i would like to see aan ultralisk,wich is like the zergs best ground unit,fight a rancor(that thing that was like 30 tall that luke killed in the return of the jedi, when he was in jabba's palace) the rancor would probably just pick up the ultralisk like a cow and eat it.


Hm...jedi vs. templar...hallucinatuon?? nah.. jedi would just use the force sense the real one and woul attack it. A lot of strom troopers were clones of jango fett and were trained ther ENTIRE lives on how to strategize and kill. while the terrans mostly have convicts and crimanals for there marines.


o yea, templar, psi-storm? jedi would just catch it and send it back at the templar, like yoda did in the movies.( in starwars RPG game, force lightning looks almost EXACTLY like psi-strom, so dont say that psi-storm has greater range)

The to ties would probably get wiped out, but cloaked wraithas dont really matter cinse all starfighters have heat signatures even when cloaked,and all starwars ships have heat seaking capabilites.

also, yea..yamoto would pwn jedi, but thats like saying id like to see tassadar dodge a death star blast, or dodge a star destoyer blast..not much of an argument.

o yes,the predictor, stardestroyeres have whats called a predictor,which after evaluating the opponents movement, will fire a laser were the enemy ship is about to go,its accuracy is like to the inch. that takes care of interceptors. stardestroyers have like a hundred guns and so it can handle more that 10 carriers and still have 20 turbolasersleft for BC. spawn brodilings wouldn't matter against a giant space station, and the death star has like a hundred times as uch guns as a death star...see my point? AND it has the power to destroy a captal ship in like one super blast. last thing,(srry folks) jedi could 1. force pull an archon off a cliff or onto there light-savers, 2. throw there light-sabers 3. all use force-lightning.4 try to Mc it, i doubt that would work tho...

my bad, my bad... also, they wouldn't need to block it, they'd just stop all of them and send them back at the enemy with the force...like neo and a xel-naga temple?? lmao, it killed all the guys on shakuras,not everything around shakuras, would help much...specialy if the death star just blew up the planet....unlike starwars planets the SC planets dont have planatery sheilds

[ColdBlue]

Well.. I don't know much about Starwars, but let's look at it this way: Starcraft units have weaknesses, so Starwars units must have weaknesses too. I'd like to see an army of clones rush into a fight versus 50 siege tanks. :D Oh yeaaa baby. So while Terran tanks own the ground, let's take a look at air. For air, I suggest a brutal fight between 145812904 X-wings against 1000 corsairs. That's right. :D . The only thing that worries me are the big ships, and the death star. But come on: death-star will go down the same way the overmind did. We'll just send Tassadar to own himself upon it. And last I recall, the damn thing blew up with a well-placed missle to a weakspot. I'm sure a wraith could do that too :D. As far as the big ships go, we'll just send our goliaths. Hell, in fact, Terran's alone could own Starwars =|.

[william_clinch]

-Why cant I say templar would win because they have more and better powers?
They probably have more powers than in the game (for balanceing reasons in the game)

-I doulbt jedi mind trick would work on most things from the starcraft universe, terrans have mental inhibitors, or psi training, zerg have no minds (except ceribrates which have uber minds) and protoss are too strong willed to be taken over like that. The only way to get mind tricks to work on things from the starcraft univers would to use a phenominal amount of energy (like the DArchon does)

-I'd say the Rancor in jabbas palace is only about 20foot tall, and the Ultralisk is taller (watch the SC:ghost trailer http://www.blizzard.com/ghost/downloads/E32004Ghost-downloader.exe)
And the rancor is just a giant fat bloke, whereas the ultralisk is a veritable war machine.

-Where as the storm troopers are just clones of a normal person, mariens have been upgraded geneticly, physicaly, and technologicaly from normal humans
And the storm troopers dont seem that intelegent from what I've seen (but that's expected from clones)
Being trained there entire lives doesnt seem that great when you realise they've only been alive for 5 years, and have just had there growth accelerated

-Try looking at the game, at the largest scale, Psi storm is bigger than a battle crusier, at the smallest, it's still several tanks wide. I'm sure most of the jedi would catch it more like mace windu did

-I agree with the X-wings haveing a chance againt the wraiths
Ties<Wraiths<X-Wings<Scout

-As the interceptors are themselves controled by computers, the 'predictor' probably wont have much sucsess, and it would take more than one puny lazer blast to shoot an interceptor down (and there are more than 10 interceptors per carrier, they reduced the numbers in game for a reason)

-The spawn broodlings thing was an (ovious) joke

-By the time a jedi got close enought to an archon to use there lightsaber, they'd already be dead, and the protoss sheild can probably stop the light saber anyway. The jedi 'force push' and 'force lightning' were just added to the game to make the jedi seem less lame, if they could realy do that, they'd be doing it constantly in the films.

-Unlike starwars, starcraft planets wouldn't nee planatary sheilds, before the deathstar even got in range, an arbiter or science vesel would be sent out to cripple it while waiting for mor ships to arive to take it down. And I'm sure the Protoss planetary weapon (in the intro) could wipe out the death star with one hit

[blaxican_templar]

i doubt an arbiter can cripple the death star very well, seeing as how its like a giant planet.... its way to big,and unlike tarcraft unts, starwars ships actually have lasers with enough range to shoot from a planet away, more that far away enough to be hurt by a merescience vessel....